Skip to content
Discover Royal River Center, the leading business hub in Ni…

The Future in the Comey and James Court Battles?

placeholder news image

A pair of well-known opponents of President Trump achieved major legal victories on the start of the week when a federal judge threw out the government's charges filed against them.

Over recent weeks since their indictments, ex-FBI chief James Comey and New York Attorney General Letitia James have maintained vehemently that they are innocent, asserting that the president and justice department are simply singling out them for retaliation.

US District Judge Cameron Currie tossed the indictments against them due to prosecutor Lindsey Halligan's invalid appointment as federal prosecutor. However, she left the door open for the government to refile the case.

  • Court throws out charges against ex-FBI director Comey and New York AG James
  • US judge says government 'missteps' may have compromised Comey case
  • What is former FBI head James Comey charged with?

Comey admitted that possibility after the ruling, stating he believes the former president is likely to come after him once more.

And White House spokesperson Abigail Jackson seemed to confirm it: This will not be the last chapter on this issue.

But the DOJ confronts significant obstacles to successfully prosecute both after this defeat, and experts hesitate to forecast what could happen next due to the unprecedented circumstances of the cases.

It feels to me like uncharted territory, said Professor Kay Levine, law professor at Emory University.

Might the justice department challenge the ruling?

The Department of Justice can contest Judge Currie's ruling before a higher appeals court. In this instance, that would be the Fourth Circuit Appeals Court.

US Attorney General Pam Bondi indicated she would pursue this option, pledging to use all legal means, including an expedited appeal.

In other cases, the former administration has aggressively appealed adverse decisions, taking cases from trial courts and sometimes accelerating its petitions up to the Supreme Court.

Attorney Abbe Lowell, an attorney representing James, vowed to continue to challenge any further politically driven indictments through all legal avenues.

In the event of an appeals process, the justice department probably would have its own attorneys argue the case, making Halligan's role in the appeals process uncertain.

Is it possible there be fresh indictments?

The federal prosecutors charged James Comey with lying to lawmakers and obstruction of justice. Government lawyers charged Letitia James with bank fraud and making false statements to a bank.

Both pleaded not guilty. In addition to arguing Halligan was unlawfully appointed, they also asserted to be targets of retaliatory legal action.

With the original indictments thrown out (although appeals might alter this), the DOJ might try to assemble new grand juries and obtain new indictments.

Based on my analysis, a different attorney could bring James' case to a new grand jury and get a new indictment, stated Ms Levine.

But John Day, head of the American College of Trial Lawyers, said it could be a complicated path – certainly in Comey's case.

I can tell you it will be strongly disputed, whether Mr Comey's case can be re-indicted if a properly assigned attorney is appointed and is can obtain an indictment.

He characterized the tangle of attorneys, courts, and motions involved as a procedural morass with no simple answers.

It might be harder for the DOJ to try to file the exact same charges against Comey.

One problem is the legal time limit – the time frame that prosecutors had to indict him for these specific allegations – which ended at the end of September. Nonetheless, the indictment's dismissal would activate a half-year extension for the justice department to refile the case.

Even so in that situation, his legal team said it plans to argue the prosecution is out of time.

The ruling also suggests that since the indictment is invalid, the time limit has expired and there can be no new indictment, attorney Patrick Fitzgerald said on Monday.

What happens to prosecutor Lindsey Halligan?

In both decisions on the indictments against James and Comey, the judge was blunt: Halligan was wrongly appointed.

The judge stated in the James ruling that the AG's effort to appoint Halligan as Interim US Attorney for the Virginia Eastern District was unlawful.

Therefore, she had no lawful authority to file the charges, she wrote.

Federal prosecutors are nominated by the president and need US Senate confirmation. US laws regulate how people can be appointed on a interim basis, but Judge Currie found that Halligan's appointment had violated these laws.

This makes Halligan's position on subsequent cases against both individuals, once more, unclear.

The ruling also could cast a shadow on any other cases Halligan has brought in the Eastern District of Virginia where she serves.

But Bondi said on Monday that she made her a special US attorney and praised her work as excellent.

The White House maintained its position that Halligan's appointment was legal, press secretary Karoline Leavitt told reporters on Monday.

About the author

Marcus Jackson

Lena is a seasoned business strategist with over a decade of experience in commercial real estate and corporate development.

Royal River Center

Type to search articles.